I found the solution.
Switch into outline view, and make sure your document is broken up into sections you desire. Every time you want to reset your page number, or change the style, you'll need a new section.
Open up inspector. Under Layout > Sections, check 'Starts at: 1', and uncheck 'Use previous headers & footers'. Finally, when inserting an auto page number, make sure the dropdown for Show In is by section, not document.